An offshore endowment is an investment or endowment policy offered by the overseas subsidiary of a South African investment platform or life insurer. The subsidiary is typically in an offshore financial centre that offers tax advantages.
These policies offer South Africans making use of their exchange control allowances the ability to invest directly offshore without the need to have a will or appoint a foreign executor for assets held in another country. They also avoid situs tax that may arise on death in a foreign country.
Offshore endowments are investment policies that offer you the ability to invest in shares held on foreign stock exchanges or funds domiciled in foreign countries in a foreign currency such as dollars or pounds.
Many South African offshore investment platforms are registered as life insurers and offer you the ability to invest through an offshore endowment from their offshore subsidiaries in international financial centres such as Guernsey, Jersey, the Isle of Man or Ireland.
The subsidiaries are registered in those countries and comply with their insurance legislation but the policy also complies with South African life insurance legislation which provides potential tax benefits for South Africans.
South African residents pay tax on their assets and investments worldwide. This means if you invest in property or a fund in another country, you need to declare it in your tax return and pay tax on the income, dividends and capital gains.
You may also be liable to tax in a foreign country. These foreign taxes may or may not be subject to double taxation agreements that ensure you do not pay tax on the same income, dividends or capital gain twice. However, you need to report your assets and any changes in them to the South African Revenue Service (SARS) on your income tax return.
When you own shares or funds in an offshore endowment that complies with South African legislation governing long-term insurance policies, the investments are held by the life insurer and it pays tax on your behalf.
This means that:
This is beneficial for high income earners who pay capital gains tax up to an effective rate up of 18 percent.
The key estate planning benefits of an offshore endowment are:
When you die with assets in another country you either need a will in that country or you need to present your original South African will in that country. Your original will is required for your South African estate which means there will be a delay presenting it to the overseas country where you have assets.
A court in another country may need to validate your will and lawyers may need to assist with this process known as probate. Some foreign countries have laws dictating who inherits (forced heirship) that may be contrary to your wishes.
A benefit of an offshore endowment is that you can name a beneficiary or beneficiaries and the proceeds of the policy can be transferred directly to them or they can take over ownership of the policy so there is no need for an offshore will or probate.
When you own assets directly in a foreign country, that country may impose its own taxes, known as situs tax, particularly when you die.
Investments in an offshore endowment, however, will not incur situs tax.
Your South African estate will still be liable for estate duty on the value of the investment, but you will not be liable for additional taxes in the country where the investment is situated.
The executor of your South African estate will also not be able to charge fees on that investment because the proceeds are paid directly to the beneficiaries.
You can contribute a lump sum or make ongoing contributions which are invested by the life insurer to provide returns on your investment.
Minimum investment amounts on offshore endowments are typically high and you need to convert your rands into the currency of the policy and make use of your exchange control allowance.
The minimum term of the policy is five years and you should check what access you will have to your money and if you commit to ongoing contributions, whether any penalties may be applied if you are unable to continue to make them.
You will typically be offered a selection of underlying investments – often mutual funds, exchange traded funds (ETFs) and even shares – on an investment platform and can switch easily between them. Some policies offer investments selected by the life insurer.
The returns you earn on the policy will depend on the performance of the underlying investments and the fees or charges you pay on it.
When the policy matures you can withdraw the investments or keep your investments in the policy as a paid-up policy. You may also be able to continue to contribute – but you should bear in mind that if you contribute more than 120% of the highest of the previous two year’s contributions a new five-year restriction on access to your investment may be applied.
If you take the proceeds, it will be paid tax-free into an offshore or local bank account.
Typically offshore endowments offered to South African investors comply with South African long term insurance legislation which means that the policy needs to be a contract with a minimum term of five years.
If you are issued with a single policy, during that period – or any longer period to which you agree – access to your money is restricted to:
However, most offshore endowments offered on investment platforms are issued as multiple policies – up to 999 policies, which means you can take withdrawals or loans against each of them.
If you are unable to continue with the policy, you can surrender it, but the life insurer may apply a penalty.
Although newer policies are issued as multiple sub-policies that work around the restrictions on access, where a single policy has been issued or is still issued and you need to change the terms of your contract – either stop contributions, withdraw your savings, transfer the policy to another provider – penalties may apply.
If your policy complies with South African long-term insurance legislation and you took out your policy after 1 January 2009, the maximum penalty you can incur is 15 percent of the policy if you terminate it early.
You may also be charged a R300 administration charge.
Older policies may incur penalties of up to 30 percent if you stop your ongoing contributions and up to 40 percent if you surrender the policy.
All endowment policies name the policyholder or any other person as the life insured and the policy will terminate on the death of the last insured person. If the policyholder and the life insured are two different people, the policy should include a beneficiary for ownership who will take over the policy should the policyholder die before the life insured.
The proceeds on the death of the insured may be restricted to the investment or may include a sum assured. On foreign endowments, the sum assured is typically a small amount and the cost of the insurance may be included in the fees instead of being disclosed seperately.
Investment policies that do not name a life insured are strictly not endowment policies but are known as sinking fund policies. These policies terminate when you as the investor withdraw the proceeds after the restricted period or you die without having named a beneficiary for ownership.
If you name a beneficiary for ownership, that beneficiary will become the new owner of the policy when you die.
Policyholders should also name a beneficiary who can be paid the proceeds should the beneficiary for ownership predecease the policyholder.
Sinking funds are generally more suitable for entities than individuals.
An endowment policy is likely to have the following charges:
You should compare the charges on your policy with that of another investment by looking at the effective annual cost (EAC) which discloses the costs you are likely to pay over the term of the product. The costs may be high but worthwhile for the other savings. A financial adviser can help you do a full cost-benefit analysis of owning your offshore investments directly or through an offshore endowment.
This article was written by Laura du Preez with input from Albert Coetzee, founder of Albert Coetzee Consulting.