The insurance lesson from a stolen phone at a cricket match

Johann Rossouw | 25 March 2025

Johann is an Associate Financial Planner at Fiscal Private Client Services. He holds the Certified Financial  Planner® accreditation and has a keen interest in personal finance and how financial markets affect our everyday lives.

Insurance is one of those things that many people only appreciate when disaster strikes. I recently learned this firsthand when my phone was stolen at an SA20 cricket match at Newlands.

What could have been a frustrating and costly ordeal turned into a relatively stress-free experience, thanks to having the right insurance in place. Within minutes of reporting the theft, my insurer issued a voucher for a replacement phone, allowing me to stay connected without financial strain.

This incident reinforced the importance of insurance in protecting against unexpected losses and highlighted several key financial considerations everyone should keep in mind.


Financial protection against unexpected loss

One of the biggest advantages of insurance is financial security. A smartphone is not just a communication tool; it’s an essential device for work, banking and daily activities. Without insurance, replacing a stolen phone would have meant an unexpected expense of thousands of rands — something few people can afford at a moment’s notice. By paying a manageable monthly premium, I avoided this financial burden and received immediate assistance when I needed it most.

 

The importance of keeping your cover updated

Many people take out insurance but fail to review their policies regularly. This can lead to gaps in coverage or outdated protection that no longer reflects the value of their possessions.

In my case, I had recently upgraded my phone, and fortunately, I had updated my policy to reflect the higher value. Had I not done so, I might have received a payout that was insufficient to replace my stolen device.

Keeping your insurance policy relevant ensures that, in the event of a loss, you receive adequate compensation. Whether it’s insurance on your home, car or personal item insurance, reviewing your cover annually and updating it after significant purchases is essential.

 

Key financial considerations

Before taking out an insurance policy, it’s crucial to evaluate several financial factors:

  • Premium vs coverage: A lower premium might seem attractive, but it could come with higher excess payments or limited coverage. Always ensure that your policy provides the right balance between affordability and protection.
  • Excess: When a claim is made, an excess is usually payable before receiving compensation. Make sure you understand what this cost is and choose an amount that fits within your budget.
  • Replacement vs market value: Some policies cover replacement value (the cost of a brand-new item), while others only pay the depreciated market value. Opting for replacement value ensures you can get an equivalent new item without out-of-pocket expenses.
  • Claim processing time: A major benefit of my insurance was how quickly the claim was processed. When choosing an insurer, research their claims process and customer service reputation to avoid lengthy delays when you need assistance.

 

Choosing the right provider

Not all insurance providers are created equal, so it’s essential to choose one that offers reliable coverage and efficient service. Here are some key factors to consider:

  • Reputation and reviews: Look for insurers with positive customer feedback, especially regarding claim settlements.
  • Claim process efficiency: Choose a provider known for quick and hassle-free claims.
  • Customer support: Responsive and helpful customer service can make all the difference in a stressful situation.
  • Policy flexibility: The ability to easily update your cover as your needs change is a crucial advantage.

Conclusion

My experience at the cricket match was a stark reminder of why insurance is essential. It protects against unexpected financial shocks, provides peace of mind, and ensures that, when the worst happens, you are not left scrambling to cover the cost.

By keeping policies updated, understanding financial implications, and choosing a reliable insurer, you can safeguard yourself against life’s unpredictable moments. If you haven’t reviewed your insurance coverage recently, now is the perfect time to do so.


HOW THE NUMBERS STACK UP

When you consider whether or not to take out insurance on a phone, consider the financial implications. Here is a practical example:

Phone cost: R32 000

Monthly insurance premiums: R130

Insurance excess: R7 000

Monthly premiums of R130 come at a cost of R1 560 annually. It would take approximately 16 years of setting aside the same amount as the premium to accumulate enough savings to purchase a new high-end smartphone outright.  

This calculation demonstrates why insurance makes particular sense for newer devices, especially for those on contracts or without substantial emergency funds. Consumers should compare offerings from various providers and consider adjusting the excess amount to optimise coverage.

In this case, despite a R7 000 excess on a R32 000 insurance policy, the policyholder could still replace their stolen device with a brand-new iPhone, a significant financial advantage over having no coverage at all. This cost-benefit analysis highlights how phone insurance can be a prudent investment, particularly for protecting valuable devices against theft.